Upgrade to Chess.com Premium!

The Pride and Sorrow of American Philosophy

Once again, the Bishop Berkeley, a friend to all and  an occasional associate of mine, sent me a quite facinating piece on an amazing contemporary of the great Paul Morphy.

The letter went as follow [I've included some photos at no extra charge]:

. . .Should you wish to, please feel free to share it with anyone who might be interested, especially with anyone who might appreciate the Chess connection....

He was born in 1839.  He invented the word "Pragmatism" and the philosophy that bears that name.  (The word itself has become part of the popular vocabulary.)  He was a friend of the man who would become America's premier Supreme Court Justice, Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr, of philosopher and psychology pioneer William James, of his (James') brother, novelist Henry James, and of many other intellectuals in their circle (including the famed "Metaphysical Club" at Harvard).  His influence on western thought has been vast -- his ideas are reflected to one degree or another in the writings of William James, John Dewey, Alfred North Whitehead, Ludwig Wittgenstein, and the "Vienna Circle".  [From Wikipedia]: Bertrand Russell opined, "Beyond doubt [...] he was one of the most original minds of the later nineteenth century, and certainly the greatest American thinker ever...."  [Alfred North] Whitehead, while reading some of [his] unpublished manuscripts soon after arriving at Harvard in 1924, was struck by how [he] had anticipated his own "process" thinking.... [Sir] Karl Popper viewed [him] as "one of the greatest philosophers of all times".  The range of his intellectual work was enormous: logic, mathematics, philosophy, semiotics, epistemology, metaphysics, the philosophy of science, etc.

   
And yet, he died in poverty and obscurity in Milford, Pennsylvania in 1914.  In one of his last letters he lamented, "I came within an ace of teaching men something to their profit.  But certain misfortunes have prevented my keeping up to the times...."  (As late as 1907, a student of William James had discovered him "ill, and near death from malnourishment, in a Cambridge rooming house." (Louis Menand, "The Metaphysical Club", p. 435))

We might easily regard him as "the pride and sorrow of American philosophy."

What is known by very few people about him is that, at the age of 55 -- struggling with financial problems as he had throughout much of his adult life -- he made an unsuccessful attempt to become a Chess columnist!  And we actually possess some of his writings on Chess (though again, they are known to very few.)  I have just placed some of them online (more about that below).

He is, of course, Charles Sanders Peirce.  (His last name is pronounced "purse," like a ladies handbag.)  Among the "demons" (to society's thinking) that troubled him throughout his life was his love of certain women of whom "polite" society did not approve -- this facilitated by his own rakish good looks (e.g.
and ) and his less-than-fully-developed monogamy.

You may read more about him at these sites:
                                                                 Site #1 
                                                                
Site #2         
                                                                 Site #3        
                                       
                                                    [or here: Site #4 ]


Almost nothing has been written about the connection C. S. Peirce had to Chess, and yet his love of the game was considerable.

One of the living authorities on the writings and thought of Peirce is Professor Richard S. Robin (retired) of Mount Holyoke College.  Professor Robin himself is quite a Chess enthusiast, and as one of the primary organizers of Peirce's papers, he was keenly aware of the Chess content of Peirce's writings.  (Professor Robin was also educated at Harvard (like Peirce).)

I have placed a copy of Professor Robin's article, "Metaphysical Reflections on Peirce on Chess" online.  It is quite thought-provoking.  I'm not sure how accurate the historical material on Paul Morphy is, but the direct content on Peirce is well worth reading.  (Professor Robin had conferred with former U.S. Chess Champion Patrick Wolff who offered his opinion that, based on his writings, C. S. Peirce was playing at about (USCF) "Expert" strength.)

As chance would have it, I happen to work with Professor Robin's son, who is a brilliant physicist and (at least in my estimation) a very fine person.  Through him, I have had the good fortune of chatting with Professor Robin on two occasions.  Now in his 80s, his enthusiasm for philosophy and Chess remains colossal!!

Click here to read Professor Robin's wonderful, "Metaphysical Reflections on Peirce on Chess"

Comments


  • 4 years ago

    BishopBerkeley

    You are most welcome, Sarah Beth and Wheeldog!

    By the way, this photo of Peirce with his wife Juliette is delightful (courtesy of the Grupo de Estudios Peirceanos):

    http://www.unav.es/gep/

    Alas, his page at Findagrave.com is conspicuously unadorned -- no virtual flowers, no notes on his contributions:

    http://tinyurl.com/6mfuph

    But I'm glad we've taken a few minutes to remember him here!

    Best wishes to all....

  • 4 years ago

    batgirl

    And thank you, Bishop Berkeley!

  • 4 years ago

    Wheeldog

    A thought provoking post -- thank you. 

  • 4 years ago

    BishopBerkeley

    Thank you for posting this, Sarah Beth!

    Sarah Beth's Site #4 above is very good, though a few of the URLs on it are out-of-date. If you adjust them, you will be taken to this very interesting website devoted to the life and thought of C.S. Peirce:

    http://www.peirce.org/

    About the best concise summary I've seen of Peirce's polymathic contributions is provided here by Max H. Fisch (a noted historian of ideas):

    "Who is the most original and the most versatile intellect that the Americas have so far produced? The answer 'Charles S. Peirce' is uncontested, because any second would be so far behind as not to be worth nominating. [He was] mathematician, astronomer, chemist, geodesist, surveyor, cartographer, metrologist, spectroscopist, engineer, inventor; psychologist, philologist, lexicographer, historian of science, mathematical economist, lifelong student of medicine; book reviewer, dramatist, actor, short story writer; phenomenologist, semiotician, logician, rhetorician and metaphysician." -Max H. Fisch in Sebeok, The Play of Musement

    Relative to 19th century America, I am inclined to agree with Professor Fisch. But I'm not sure we can extend this back into the 18th century! Some of the founders of the United States of America had very impressive intellectual achievements over a wide range of subjects: Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, John Adams, etc. (And we know at least three of these men were Chess players! See: http://www.monticello.org/reports/quotes/chess.html )

    In this connection, British philosopher Alfred North Whitehead (who is mentioned above in connection with C.S. Peirce) was quite an admirer of the founders of the United States. According to (American) Lucien Price, this was his opinion:

    ""I know of only two occasions in history when the people in power did what needed to be done about as well as you can imagine it being possible. One was the framing of your American Constitution. They were able statesmen, they had access to a body of good ideas; they incorporated these general principles into the instrument without trying to particularize too explicitly how they should be put into effect; and they were men of immense practical experience themselves. The other was in Rome, and it undoubtedly saved civilization for, roughly, about four hundred years. It was the work of Augustus and the set around him. He saved Rome from the Romans -- I mean the city Romans -- from the bankruptcy of the republican form of government, and the dessicated ideas of the old patrician class. . . . It was one of the great achievements of human history and I doubt if, after all the legalistic analysis has been done, anybody quite understands how the thing was accomplished."

    from "Dialogues of Alfred North Whitehead," p. 158, as recorded by Lucien Price, copyright 1954 by the Executors of the Estate of Alfred North Whitehead, ISBN: 1-56792-129-9

    For Americans, our nation is very fortunate to have produced persons of such genius!  Of course, we are by no mean unique in this (nor would we wish to be), but we are happy when we are graced with such brilliance (as in the case of the Chess "super genius" Paul Morphy -- to use Garry Kasparov's apt description of the lad from New Orleans!)

    Thank you again, Sarah Beth, and best wishes to all!

    (: Bishop Berkeley :)

  • 4 years ago

    staggerlee

    Very cool!  Thanks so much for sharing this.  I'm a big fan of Peirce.  I wrote my undergraduate thesis on his philosophy!

  • 4 years ago

    farbror

    Very interesting! C.S. Peirce is one of my favourite philosophers.

Back to Top

Post your reply: