New Pin Theory, Black Redemption

Submitted by sam_musil on Sun, 06/28/2009 at 1:36am.

I just completed my third game with my good friend sergio61 from Turin, Italy.  He is a fine player and crushed my Sicilian Defense Pin Variation in our first game.  He destroyed a line that I had played for over 30 years and sent me back to the drawing board.  I used Chess.com, Fritz, and Chessmaster to look at several positions in the game for the necessary P.N. (Personal Novelty) in the Sam Musil opening repetoire.  The improvement 10. .. Nc6 has been played before in the master database in a computer vs. computer game, so we do not have to argue about a T.N. (Theoretical Novelty), but it is a PN that leads to an even or slightly better game for black after just 21 moves.   This game was part of a match between Team Italy and Team USA South Central where the USA team was behind 78 to 6 when I offered the draw before my move 21.  Sergio accepted my draw offer because he claimed the game was even and he had too many other games to continue the hard fight against me.

Of course, I think that black is slightly ahead and sergio thinks that the game is even.  I would have played on if this was a close match or a tournament game.  At this time I am involved in 78 games at Chess.com and winning from sergio would take me at least 3 to 6 months of hard work, so we agreed to the draw.  This is the latest theory in the main line of the Schoenmann Variation (7. Bd2) which was introduced by Wilhelm Schoenmann in the German Championship of 1935.  Chess is supposed to be above politics, but Wilhelm does not get the credit that he deserves for introducing the line and

winning the inaugural game with it because it was played under the Nazi regime!  This variation is still the most popular line chosen against the Pin Koch Variation, so the theory is important!  The final position is very interesting and has a lot of play left in it!

» posted in sam_musil's Blog
 

Comments:

by sam_musil - 4 months ago
Marysville, Kansas United States
Member Since: Jan 2008
Member Points: 266

chessrobo ,

You asked about 6. .. Qa5? in an interesting question.  I include the remaining score of my last game in the line:

by chessrobo - 4 months ago
International
Member Since: Apr 2009
Member Points: 23

What about 6...Qa5 ?

by sam_musil - 4 months ago
Marysville, Kansas United States
Member Since: Jan 2008
Member Points: 266

Grinning_Crow ,

Yes, I agree that 22. cb6 ab6 23. R:b6 N:d6 gives black a huge advantage, probably a direct win with the center pawn-storm.  White would not play cb6 as he cannot afford to drop the d-pawn!  This line is why black is better here!

I did not go into all the threats here, but I should have mentioned that cb6 is not playable in the final position.  Thanks for your contribution.

Sincerely,  Sam

by Grinning_Crow - 4 months ago
United Kingdom
Member Since: Jun 2009
Member Points: 1

I have a feeling that

22 cb6 Kxd6

may have kept the initiative

by sam_musil - 4 months ago
Marysville, Kansas United States
Member Since: Jan 2008
Member Points: 266

JG27Pyth ,

I agree that black is better and the chess.com computer said that black was 0.19 pawns ahead in the final position, but I have too many games going to fight for the win in a meaningless game with the match lost 78 to 6 .  This is now published theory and the final position will be contested in later master games!

mueller ,

Yes, I wasted the novelty in the sense that I did not gain the win in a slightly superior position, but against strong opponents (above 2600) like Sergio, a draw with black should be an acceptable result in a round-robin tourney.  In the first tourney that I won at Chess.com, I offered a draw in a slightly superior position to secure the championship!  Also, this was a line where my previous defense had been crushed by Sergio, so the draw was a vast improvement!

I want to thank all commentors to my blog; I appreciate the feedback.

Sincerely,  Sam

by JG27Pyth - 4 months ago
NYC United States
Member Since: Mar 2008
Member Points: 1333

I don't see the draw. I think Black is better...

by mueller - 4 months ago
United States
Member Since: Feb 2008
Member Points: 230

While I understand the game is essentially even at the end, it doesnt really seem drawn to me. I guess your comment about playing too many games and it being too much work to finish properly makes sense, but it seems a shame to waste the novelty of 10...Nc6 on a game that was drawn with so much life left in it.

Good luck in the rest of your games with this opening, and I'll see if I can incorporate the Schoenmann into my repertoire.

by sam_musil - 4 months ago
Marysville, Kansas United States
Member Since: Jan 2008
Member Points: 266

bigfundu ,

I am really glad that you enjoyed the game.  I expect to explore the position further in the near future as white opponents continue to try the Schoenmann against my Pin Defense.

I hope that all my fellow Pin afficienadoes will use this line against the Schoenmann as I believe that my defense is sound and will stand up to futher testing.

Sincerely,  Sam

by bigfundu - 4 months ago
Chennai India
Member Since: Oct 2008
Member Points: 379

Nice game! It was a damn good attack and very good defense.

 

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.